New York City, the city that never sleeps, is not only famous for its skyscrapers, multicultural neighborhoods, and world-class museums but also a culinary paradise with countless enticing options. Among these, seafood always holds a special place, especially dishes made from the freshest ingredients. If you are a seafood lover and looking for memorable culinary experiences in New York, this article is for you. Let’s explore the best seafood restaurants and dishes where you can savor the authentic taste of the ocean right in the heart of this vibrant city.
Top-Rated Seafood “Gems” in New York
Delmonico’s: Traditional Lobster Newberg Flavor
If you want to experience a dish with historical significance, visit Delmonico’s, one of the oldest restaurants in New York. Here, you can enjoy the renowned Lobster Newberg, a recipe created in 1876. This dish is a perfect combination of fresh lobster, fortified wine or Sherry, cream, butter, and eggs.
Lobster Newberg at Delmonico's, a historic dish in New York City
Although Lobster Newberg is not as common today as it once was, Delmonico’s remains one of the few restaurants that preserve this traditional recipe. At Delmonico’s, you not only enjoy a delicious dish but also experience a piece of New York’s culinary history.
- Address: 56 Beaver St Frnt A, New York, NY
- Phone: 212 509 1144
- Website: https://www.delmonicos.com/
- Price: Ranging from $19 to $40
Elegant and classic interior of Delmonico's restaurant
Perry St: French-Asian Culinary Fusion in Lobster Thermidor
If you are looking for a twist in flavor, visit Perry St and try their special Lobster Thermidor. This dish retains the basic ingredients of traditional Thermidor such as cream, egg yolks, and white wine, but adds a layer of crispy golden-brown Gruyere cheese.
The highlight of Lobster Thermidor at Perry St is the fusion of French and Asian cuisine. Shiitake mushrooms and spicy Thai chili add a unique flavor, making the dish distinct from other Thermidor versions.
- Address: 176 Perry St, New York, NY 10014
- Phone: +353 21 427 8776
- Website: https://www.perrystrestaurant.com/mobile/reservation/
The Grill: “Mini” Lobster with Exquisite Flavor
At The Grill, you will enjoy lobster in a completely new style. Lobster is cut into bite-sized pieces and served with a special sauce. This dish is prepared with classic cheese and tomatoes, creating a flavor different from Lobster Newberg.
The Grill offers a luxurious and reminiscent space of extravagance, where you can enjoy a delicious and memorable meal.
- Address: 346 E 21st St, New York, NY 10010-5621
- Website: https://www.restaurantji.com/ny/new-york/grill-21-/
Cozy and luxurious ambiance at The Grill restaurant
Pearl Oyster Bar: Famous Lobster Roll
Pearl Oyster Bar is an ideal place to enjoy classic seafood with top-notch cooking techniques and a touch of New York “style.” In particular, the lobster roll here is very famous and highly rated by the press.
Besides the lobster roll, Pearl Oyster Bar is also known for its Pearl Caesar and smoked clam chowder, as well as delicious sandwiches for lunch.
- Address: 18 Cornelia St (btw Bleecker & W 4th) New York, NY 10014
- Phone: (212) 691-8211
- Website: https://www.pearlkennebunk.com
Olmsted: Unique Lobster Thermidor Biscuits
Olmsted brings an innovative twist to the traditional Lobster Thermidor. Instead of serving lobster in the usual way, this restaurant turns lobster into crispy biscuits served with Thermidor sauce.
The combination of crispy biscuits, white wine, Gruyere cheese, and cream creates a completely new culinary experience. What many people love about this dish is its affordable price, not as expensive as other lobster dishes.
- Address: 659 Vanderbilt Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11238
- Phone: 716-838-1249
- Email: [email protected]
City Lobster and Steak Co.: Delicious Lobster at Affordable Prices
City Lobster and Steak Co. is a famous spot for delicious lobster dishes with unique flavors. However, some diners commented that the lobster meat here is not very tender.
Besides lobster, this restaurant is also famous for its veal. City Lobster and Steak Co. is located in Midtown West and is always crowded during meal times.
- Address: 121 W 49th St, New York, NY 10020, USA
- Phone: +1 212-354-1717
Nick’s Lobster Fish Market: Fresh Live Lobster From the Tank
If you are a lover of fresh live lobster, then Nick’s Lobster Fish Market is a must-visit. Here, lobsters are caught directly from a 300-gallon tank in the back for preparation.
With absolute freshness, prices at Nick’s Lobster Fish Market are not cheap. However, if you want to enjoy the freshest lobster flavor, this is a worthwhile option.
- Address: 2777 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY
- Phone: +1 718-253-7117
Urban Lobster: Lobster Delivery to Your Door
Urban Lobster is a unique restaurant specializing in lobster delivery to homes in the Lower East Side / Alphabet City areas. With a menu of low-carb side dishes, Urban Lobster is a great option for dieters.
The restaurant’s staff is very enthusiastic, the food quality is high, and delivery is fast.
- Address: 240 E. Houston Ave
- Phone: 207.956.7051
Wild Edibles: Seafood Delivery With Excellent Flavor
Similar to Urban Lobster, Wild Edibles offers seafood delivery to customers. However, prices here are significantly higher.
Lobster dishes at Wild Edibles have excellent flavor, but some customers complain about the staff’s attitude.
- Address: Inc. 740 Barry Street. Bronx, NY 10474
- Phone: 718.860.1000
Luke’s Lobster: Delicious Lobster at Budget Prices
Luke’s Lobster is an ideal place to enjoy lobster dishes at affordable prices. The dishes here have many flavors and are very delicious.
However, Luke’s Lobster is usually quite small and crowded, so you should consider takeaway if you don’t want to wait.
- Address: 93 E.7
Ed’s Lobster Bar: Fresh Lobster in a Bar Setting
Ed’s Lobster Bar serves many lobster dishes, from fresh lobster to grilled lobster. The dishes here are delicious, but the prices are quite high.
The restaurant’s space is decorated like a bar, with wall-facing seats, so it’s not an ideal place if you want to chat with the person opposite you.
- Address: 222 Lafayette St. Manhattan
- Phone: 212-343-3236
Conclusion
New York is a culinary paradise with countless attractive seafood options. Whether you want to enjoy traditional dishes or new creations, you can find restaurants that suit your taste. Hopefully, this list will help you discover the best seafood in New York and have memorable culinary experiences. Bon appétit and have a wonderful trip!