New York City is not only the city of dreams but also a culinary paradise, a melting pot of global gastronomic excellence. If you are a seafood enthusiast, especially a lobster lover, then New York is an unmissable destination. With countless seafood restaurants ranging from budget-friendly to upscale, finding the best spots to savor delicious lobster dishes can be an exciting quest.
So, where are the best seafood restaurants in New York that you must visit to enjoy the renowned lobster dishes? Join “Travel the Globe” as we explore famous locations where you can experience the freshest, most unique, and unforgettable lobster flavors in this vibrant city.
Delmonico’s: The Legendary Lobster Newberg
When it comes to lobster in New York, Delmonico’s, a long-standing culinary icon of the city, is indispensable. Established in 1837, Delmonico’s is not just a restaurant; it’s a piece of New York history.
Dish of Lobster Newberg at Delmonico's, New York
Delmonico’s is famous for Lobster Newberg, a recipe created in 1876. This dish is a perfect combination of fresh lobster, fortified wine or Sherry, cream, butter, and eggs. Over the years, Lobster Newberg has become increasingly rare, but at Delmonico’s, you can still enjoy this iconic dish made according to the traditional recipe.
Delmonico’s is located at 56 Beaver St Frnt A, New York City. Prices range from $19 to $40 per dish.
- Contact: 212 509 1144
- Website: https://www.delmonicos.com/
Perry St.: Refined Lobster Thermidor
If you want to experience a unique Lobster Thermidor, head to Perry St. Instead of the traditional recipe, Perry St. offers a Thermidor version with a French-Asian flair.
Lobster Thermidor at Perry St., New York
The highlight of this dish is the appealing crispy brown Gruyere cheese crust, combined with shiitake mushrooms and spicy Thai chili peppers. This combination creates a unique, unforgettable flavor.
Perry St. is located at 176 Perry St, New York, NY 10014.
- Contact: +353 21 427 8776
- Website: https://www.perrystrestaurant.com/mobile/reservation/
The Grill: Contemporary Lobster Style
The Grill offers a completely different lobster experience. Here, lobster is served in bite-sized pieces with a novel sauce. The lobster dish here is prepared with classic cheese and tomatoes, reminiscent of past luxury.
Lobster dish at The Grill, New York
The Grill is located at 346 E 21st St, New York, NY 10010-5621.
Pearl Oyster Bar: Flavors of the Sea
Pearl Oyster Bar is an ideal place to enjoy seafood in a classic style, combining top-notch culinary techniques and distinctive New York style. The lobster roll here is delicious and famous, praised by many newspapers. In addition, Pearl Oyster Bar is also loved for its Pearl Caesar salad and smoked clam chowder.
Pearl Oyster Bar is located at 18 Cornelia St (btw Bleecker & W 4th) New York, NY 10014.
- Contact: (212) 691-8211
- Website: https://www.pearlkennebunk.com
Olmsted: Innovative Lobster Thermidor
Olmsted brings the most special innovation to Lobster Thermidor in New York. The restaurant has transformed a traditional lobster dish into a completely new and more accessible dish: lobster biscuits with Thermidor sauce. The combination of crispy biscuits, wine, Gruyere cheese, and cream creates an exciting and surprising experience.
Olmsted is located at 659 Vanderbilt Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11238.
- Contact: 716-838-1249
- Email: [email protected]
City Lobster and Steak Co.: Traditional Lobster
City Lobster and Steak Co. is an excellent choice if you want to enjoy traditional lobster with a unique flavor. Although the lobster meat here is not very tender, the taste is worth trying. In addition to lobster, the restaurant is also famous for its veal dishes. City Lobster and Steak Co. is located in Midtown West at 121 W. 49th. Prices here range from $31 to $50 per dish.
- Contact: +1 212-354-1717
- Address: 121 W 49th St, New York, NY 10020, USA
Nick’s Lobster Fish Market: Absolute Freshness
If you are a fan of fresh, live lobster, Nick’s Lobster Fish Market is a must-visit. Lobsters here are caught directly from a 300-gallon tank in the back for processing, ensuring absolute freshness. However, with such freshness, the prices here are not cheap, ranging from $95 to $550 for a lobster dish.
Nick’s Lobster Fish Market is located at 2777 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn.
- Contact: +1 718-253-7117
Urban Lobster: Lobster at Home
Urban Lobster provides home delivery of lobster in the Lower East Side / Alphabet City areas. The low-carb side dishes here are perfect for dieters. Prices here range from $20 to $30 per dish.
- Contact: 207.956.7051
Wild Edibles: Premium Delivery
Similar to Urban Lobster, Wild Edibles offers home delivery to customers, but at a higher price point. The lobster dishes here have great flavor, but the service may not be as attentive. Prices here range from $23 to $92 for a lobster dish.
- Address: Inc. 740 Barry Street. Bronx, NY 10474
- Contact: 718.860.1000
Luke’s Lobster: Affordable Prices
Luke’s Lobster is an excellent option if you want to enjoy lobster at an affordable price, ranging from $10-20 per dish. The lobster dishes here come in many flavors and are delicious. However, this place is quite small, you should consider takeout as it is often crowded.
Dish of Lobster Newberg at Delmonico's, New York
Luke’s Lobster is located at 93 E.7th.
Ed’s Lobster Bar: Lobster Variety
Ed’s Lobster Bar serves a variety of lobster dishes, from fresh lobster to grilled lobster. The lobster dishes here are delicious, but the prices are quite high.
Ed’s Lobster Bar is located at 222 Lafayette St. Manhattan.
- Contact: 212-343-3236
Conclusion
New York City is a paradise for lobster lovers. With countless seafood restaurants, you can easily find the best lobster dishes, from traditional recipes to unique creations. Hopefully, this list will help you have a wonderful culinary experience in this vibrant city. Don’t forget to explore more delicious lobster spots in New England for a complete culinary journey!